How to IRL This site is new and not complete. Something wrong? Let us know

Why more than one network?

A stream needs a steady upload, every second. One connection, even a fast one, has short moments when it can't give that. A second network covers those moments.

Why one modem isn't enough, even a fast one 

Say your modem can upload 50 Mbps, and your stream needs 6 Mbps. That sounds like plenty. But 50 is the best case. Your stream needs its 6 Mbps every second, also in the worst second. Here is what gets in the way.

The speed on the box is the best case 

A modem's top speed is what it can do with a perfect signal and a cell tower to itself. A plan's top speed is a best case too. In the US, the official label on a plan also shows a typical upload speed. In Germany, the plan's fact sheet shows an estimated maximum. What you really get depends on the cell tower near you, at that moment.

Upload: the top speed against what you really get A dashed line at the top is the top speed on the box. A thick line below it is what you really get. It goes up and down, far below the top speed. A thin line near the bottom is what your stream needs. Twice, what you get drops under it for a moment. Those moments are shaded. Top speed You get Needed

A cell tower is shared by everyone near it 

Each cell tower has a set amount of capacity. Everyone connected to it shares it. On a quiet street, you get a big share. At a concert, a match or a busy station, thousands of phones use the same tower. Then your upload can drop a lot, even with full signal bars.

One cell tower, shared Two scenes side by side. On a quiet street, your phone has a thick line to the cell tower: a big share of its capacity. At a busy place, the same tower has ten phones around it, and each one, yours too, has only a thin line to it: a small share. Quiet Busy You

The signal changes as you move 

The farther you are from the tower, the weaker your signal. Walls, buildings and coated glass block a lot of it. Your own body blocks some too, more on the higher 5G bands. So the signal changes with every few steps, and even with how you hold the phone or wear the backpack.

The signal near the tower and behind a building A cell tower, a phone near it and a building further away with a second phone behind it. The near phone has a thick line to the tower: a strong signal. The line to the far phone is thick up to the building and only dashed behind it: the building blocks much of the signal. Near Blocked

Switching towers pauses the link 

As you move, your phone or modem switches from one tower to the next. This is called a handover. During each switch, data stops for a moment. In one study, the pause was about 25 ms (thousandths of a second) on average, and sometimes over 100 ms. In another study, a full switch on 5G took about 170 ms on average. On a motorway, 5G switched towers about every 400 metres.

One pause is short, and a streaming app can wait it out. But on the move it happens again and again, often where the signal is weak anyway.

A handover from one tower to the next Two cell towers and your phone at three moments as you walk from one to the other. First it is linked to the first tower. In the shaded middle it switches and is linked to neither. Then it is linked to the second tower. Underneath, your data runs as a thick line that breaks off in the middle: during the switch, nothing gets through. Switch Data

Some plans wait in line 

When a tower is busy, a carrier may serve some plans before others. At a quiet tower, all of them get through. One US carrier's terms say that on certain plans, it "may prioritize your 5G and 4G LTE data behind other traffic" when the cell site is busy. So at a busy place, two people at the same tower can get very different upload. Each plan's terms say whether it has this. More on the limits behind "unlimited".

A busy tower serves one plan first A busy cell tower. The priority plan's packets, filled squares, move to the tower one after another. The other plan's packets, empty squares, are bunched up in a queue, and only one at a time moves on. Priority Other plan

Upload is the weak direction 

Your phone sends with much less power than the tower. So upload fades first: at the edge of coverage, download can still be fast while upload is already slow. A stream is almost all upload. More in Upload first.

Strong download, weak upload A cell tower with large radio waves and your phone with one small wave. From the tower to the phone runs a thick arrow: the download. From the phone back to the tower runs a thin arrow: the upload, which carries your stream. Download Upload

Put together: one connection is fast most of the time, but it has short bad moments. With only one connection, your viewers see each of those moments as a freeze or a drop.

Sources

Best case: FCC Broadband Labels, TK-Transparenzverordnung § 1. Shared towers: a carrier's help page on shared capacity, the German regulator's FAQ on events. Signal: ITU on building loss, the 3GPP channel model (section 7.6.4, blocking by people). Handover: an LTE drive test (VTC 2016), a 5G drive test across the US (SIGCOMM 2022). Priority: a network management page, plan terms. Upload: 3GPP phone power classes, Ericsson on uplink coverage. The handover numbers come from drive tests in Denmark and the US, on the networks of that time. Yours can differ.

How a second network helps 

Bonding sends your stream over two or more connections at the same time. It works best when the connections are as different as possible.

Different networks rarely fail at the same moment 

Two carriers have their own towers, in different places, on different radio bands, with different crowds. When one is weak, the other is often fine. In a drive test in Denmark, phones on three networks switched towers many times along 130 km. The three networks never switched at the same moment. With two different networks together, the time lost to switching was about 60 times shorter than with one.

One network dips while the other carries on Three lines over time. Network 1 gets weak for a while. Network 2 is fine at that moment, and gets weak later, when network 1 is fine again. Your stream, sent over both, keeps going the whole time. Network 1 Network 2 Your stream

Bonding splits the stream into small pieces 

Your app cuts the stream into small packets, about 1,300 bytes each. With SRTLA, the open bonding protocol many IRL apps use, the sender sends each packet over the link that has the most room at that moment. A receiver on the internet collects the packets from every link. It puts them back in order and passes one stream on to OBS or the platform.

A faster link gets more packets. A link that loses packets gets fewer. If a packet goes missing, the receiver asks for it again, and the resend can take another link. This is why bonding needs a delay buffer: the SRT latency setting is the time the receiver waits for late and resent packets.

Pieces over two networks, joined at the receiver Your app sends numbered pieces of the stream over two networks. Pieces 1, 3 and 4 go over network 1. Pieces 2 and 5 go over network 2. The receiver gets all of them and puts them back in order: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. App Receiver 43152 1 2 3 4 5
How SRTLA picks a link
  • Room on each link: for every link, the sender counts the packets that are on their way and not yet confirmed. It also keeps a window, a guess of how many packets that link can carry. Each new packet goes to the link with the most free room in its window.
  • Confirmations: the receiver confirms packets on the link they came in on. A link whose packets keep getting confirmed gets a bigger window.
  • Losses: when the receiver reports a lost packet, the window of the link that carried it shrinks. So a link that gets worse quickly gets fewer packets.
  • A silent link: if a link sends nothing back for 4 seconds, the sender leaves it out until it answers again.
  • Order and resends are SRT's job. Every packet has a number, so the SRT receiver can put them in order and ask for the missing ones. SRTLA itself doesn't control the bitrate. Your app has to lower it when all links get weak (adaptive bitrate).

This is how the BELABOX SRTLA sender works. Other apps that speak SRTLA may balance their links a little differently.

Links add up 

Say each of two links gives 4 Mbps at a busy place. Together they give almost 8. So you can keep a higher bitrate than either link could carry alone. The total is a little less than the sum, because bonding sends some extra data and the links have different delays.

Two links add up Three bars. Link 1 and link 2 are the same length. The bar for both together is almost as long as the two put end to end; a small dashed piece at its end is missing. A thin upright line marks a bitrate that is longer than either link alone, but shorter than both together. Link 1 Link 2 Together Bitrate

The stream stops only when every link is bad 

With one connection, every bad moment reaches your viewers. With bonding, a bad moment on one link only matters when the other links are bad at the same moment. The sender moves the packets to the links that still work.

A sudden drop can still cause a short glitch. That happens when packets that were on the failing link can't be sent again before the latency runs out. A longer SRT latency gives more time for that.

Your stream stops only when both networks are weak Three lines over time. Network 1 gets weak for a while. Network 2 gets weak a little later. For a short time, both are weak together; that time is shaded. Your stream, sent over both, keeps going, except in that shaded time. Network 1 Network 2 Your stream
Sources

The Danish drive test (ICC 2018); the SRTLA README and the SRTLA sender's source code; the SRT protocol draft, Haivision on SRT latency; the packet size as in What the extra is. The drive test sent a copy of every packet over each network. Bonding splits the stream instead. I assume the networks' bad moments line up the same way in both cases, but that test didn't measure a split stream. The 4 + 4 example is made up to show the idea.

The limits 

Two SIMs on the same network help less 

Two SIMs from the same carrier use the same towers and share the same crowd. In a full cell or a dead spot, both get weak together. They still help a little with handovers: in the Danish drive test, two phones on the same network rarely switched at the same moment. But two different networks did about twice as well. Many cheaper brands use one of the big networks, so check which one before you buy a second SIM.

Two networks against the same network Two scenes side by side, each with your box and its two SIMs. On the left, each SIM has a line to a different cell tower, one on each network. On the right, both SIMs have a line to the same cell tower. Two networks Same network

It uses more data 

Bonding sends a little extra: packet headers, confirmations on every link, and resent packets. In total that's about 10 % on top of your bitrate, a little more with bonding and loss. If your app sends a full copy over each link (redundant mode), the data use grows with every link. And one link may end up carrying most of the stream, so choose each plan as if it carries all of it. Work out your own in the data calculator.

The extra data, split or copied Two rows of bars. Top, bonding that splits the stream: one bar for your stream and a small dashed piece at its end, the extra. Bottom, a full copy on each of two links: the same bar and dashed piece twice, so about twice the data. Split Redundant

It doesn't fix the camera or the encoder 

Bonding only carries the stream. A dark, shaky or blurry picture stays the same. So does a phone or encoder that is too hot or too slow, and a wrong setting in OBS or on the platform.

Where bonding sits Four boxes in a column with arrows between them: camera, phone or encoder, bonding, then OBS or the platform. Only the bonding box is marked: bonding carries the stream between the encoder and OBS or the platform, and changes nothing in the other boxes. Camera Encoder Bonding OBS

More modems need more power and cooling 

Every phone or modem uses power and gets warm while it sends, more so with a weak signal. Two phones or four modems drain a battery faster, and in a backpack the heat has to get out. Tips to keep a phone cool.

Keep modems and their antennas apart, and watch the USB cables. A fast USB 3 link gives off radio noise that can make a modem next to it hear the tower worse. On my test setup, setting a modem's USB to the slower USB 2 speed made its signal clearer. A bonding link doesn't need more than USB 2.

Sources

The Danish drive test (ICC 2018), with two phones on the same network; the extra data as in What the extra is; a phone maker on weak signal and heat; Intel's paper on USB 3 radio noise (it measured Wi-Fi and Bluetooth; the effect on a mobile modem is from my own tests: clear on one band, small or none on two others)

Where next